News
Mahmud and Etnire Win Vermont
Colin Etnire '12 and Ian Mahmud '12 took 1st place at the 2009 University of Vermont tournament. Credit: Geoffrey Etnire
Bates sophomores Ian Mahmud and Colin Etnire won the Robert Huber Memorial Debates at the University of Vermont last weekend, finishing first out of a field of 76 teams. Andrew Wong '12 and Micrea Lupu '11 broke to the quarterfinal round, and Ariela Silberstein '10 and Nate Sweet '11 narrowly missed the break, finishing just one place behind the final team chosen. Etnire was also named 3rd place Varsity speaker.
The championship is the largest tournament (by field size) that Bates has won, possibly since the University of Pennsylvania in 1994, certainly since early 1995, and only the second tournament of any size since 2005. The winning pair was seeded 4th overall heading into the break, and won the final round as the second government team supporting the motion, "This House would allow Iran to acquire nuclear weapons."
The championship victory also marked the first time that Etnire and Mahmud had broken at a varsity level in any tournament, after accumulating only novice breaks last year as freshmen.
Vermont was the first British Parliamentary (BP) style tournament that any of the four breaking debaters had taken place in, and their first practice rounds in the style occurred less than a week prior to the tournament. British style is different from American style in that the motions are "closed" (determined by those who run the tournament, rather than the debaters themselves) and that four teams are in each round instead of two. BP is the style used in all major international competitions.
All three pairs were sent to UVM in preparations for international debating. UVM was the first stop in the prep cycle, with Yale's IV tournament in late October, the Oxford and Cambridge championships in the middle of November, and finally the World Championships hosted by Koc University in southern Turkey at the end of the year.
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=debad5d2-d9ce-476c-b073-9c6815942771)